Done the long way, six days a week.
Dough mixed fresh every morning, sauce simmered in house, pies built to order. Take-out, delivery and catering trays out of our West Babylon kitchen.
Ordering direct sends your ticket straight to our screen. Pick your pie, pick your time, and it’s hot when you get here.
The menu on this site is the Wheatley Heights menu. West Babylon runs its own, so a few sections here are not on it - check before you order.