Margherita Sicilian with crushed tomato and basil, cooling on a rack

Pizza in West Babylon.

1185 Straight Path, West Babylon, NY 11704

Lunch, dinner and everything in between.

Pizza, pasta, heroes and Italian favorites, open six days a week. Grab a quick lunch, feed the family, or call our West Babylon shop ahead for a bigger order.

Order online for pickup or delivery. Ordering direct skips the delivery-app markup, and your ticket goes straight to our kitchen.

The menu on this site is the Wheatley Heights menu. West Babylon runs its own, so a few sections here are not on it - check before you order.

Also available on

Google reviews

What West Babylon is saying.

  • “Always delicious, amazing customer service and great prices!!!”
    Jennifer M.Google review
  • “Chicken cutlets cooked to perfection!!”
    David M.Google review
  • “Slices are all fresh and delicious!”
    Fabio A.Google review