Pepperoni Sicilian finished with fresh basil

Wheatley Heights · West Babylon

Your neighborhoodpizza spot.

Pizza, pasta, heroes and Italian comfort food for lunch, dinner and everything in between. Order direct for pickup or delivery.

View the menu

Wheatley Heights
4 Colonial Springs Rd
Order online
West Babylon
1185 Straight Path
Order online

View the menu

Grandma SquareChicken ParmigianaPenne Alla VodkaGarlic KnotsTrio SicilianGrilled Chicken Caesar Salad PizzaBuffalo ChickenPinwheelsStromboliCannoli

The menu

What’s on the menu.

All 125 items

Pies

Grandma squares, Sicilians, and twenty-five specialty pies.

See the menu

Chicken cutlet sandwiches on rolls, finished with parsley

Heroes

Fifteen heroes. Chicken parm, cutlet alla vodka, cold Italian.

See the menu

Catering

Pizzas, pastas, salads and heroes for the office or the family party.

See the menu

A Wheatley Heights favorite

A local spot built on good food.

Bonilla’s is the neighborhood place for pizza, pasta, heroes and satisfying Italian favorites. Whether you’re picking up a quick lunch, feeding the family or ordering dinner for a group, we’re here to make it easy and make it good.

125Items on the menu, pies to heroes
2 kitchensWheatley Heights & West Babylon
11am–9pmMonday to Saturday
Order aheadSkip the wait, walk in to it hot

View the menu Our story

The Bonilla's kitchen crew at the deck oven during a rush

A square Sicilian slice lifted from the pie, mozzarella stretching in long strands

Built to order

Google reviews

What our customers say.

“I know gas station pizza? It's great.”
Kathleen B.Wheatley Heights · Google review
“Always delicious, amazing customer service and great prices!!!”
Jennifer M.West Babylon · Google review
“I spoke with the owner who was patient and assured me they would take care of everything.”
Liz D.Wheatley Heights · Google review
“Chicken Penne Al Vodka slice was next level”
Aidan A.Wheatley Heights · Google review
“Chicken cutlets cooked to perfection!!”
David M.West Babylon · Google review
“This pizza is so good! Good price too.”
Ashley B.Wheatley Heights · Google review
“I stumbled upon this hidden gem while searching for a place that served vodka margarita pizzas.”
DaliahWheatley Heights · Google review
“Slices are all fresh and delicious!”
Fabio A.West Babylon · Google review
“Their pizza sauce and crispy crust is amazing.”
Baldeep S.Wheatley Heights · Google review
“Just the plain pizza pie was above and beyond.”
Ahmed A.Wheatley Heights · Google review

Wheatley Heights

Read reviews Leave a review

West Babylon

Read reviews Leave a review

Real food, real photos

Hungry yet? Check out our gallery.

Check out our gallery

Find us

Two locations.

Wheatley Heights

4 Colonial Springs RdWheatley Heights, NY 11798(631) 643-5175

Monday to Saturday: 11am to 9pm
Sunday: Closed

Order from Wheatley Heights Directions Details

West Babylon

1185 Straight PathWest Babylon, NY 11704(516) 927-0326

Monday to Saturday: 11am to 9pm
Sunday: Closed

Order from West Babylon Directions Details

Catering

Feeding a crowd? Call it in.

Communions, team dinners, office lunches, game day. Pizzas, pastas, salads and heroes, built into a spread for your room. Call it in and we will help you pick.

Wheatley Heights (631) 643-5175 West Babylon (516) 927-0326